Corona Lessons
Consultancy.nl | Vocational students and teachers: “100% online education doesn’t work”
Consultancy.nl highlights the study conducted by Turner on the lessons learned from the COVID-19 pandemic, which surveyed 5,000 students, faculty, and staff members from sixteen educational institutions. Read the full article written by Consultancy.nl.
Vocational high school students and teachers: “100% online education doesn’t work”
For many students, online education has been the norm for quite some time. Although distance learning has offered numerous benefits for both students and instructors, 100% online education is not desirable. This is according to a study by the management consulting firm Turner.
For the study, researchers at Turner surveyed approximately 2,400 vocational education students and 2,600 vocational education teachers about their experiences with education during the COVID-19 crisis. The main conclusion is that, according to the majority of students and teachers, 100% online education is undesirable. However, opinions differ between teachers and students regarding the exact reasons for their objections.
Students
In general, students rate project-based and hands-on learning, as well as interactive teaching methods used in class, less favorably. Additionally, at half of the institutions, students have negative views about the class schedules: they complain about unclear schedules, poor communication, and classes that overlap.
“Students also say they miss having sufficient structure in their schedules,” according to the researchers. “Furthermore, students say they regret that large portions of their Education have sometimes been canceled.”
In addition, many students report that while they can reasonably follow education from home, they do experience a lot of distractions, such as from family members or roommates. Many students also report finding it difficult to motivate themselves and organize their schoolwork: “Students say that, in general, they are not learning as well as they did before the COVID-19 crisis and are less able to apply what they’ve learned and put it into practice.”
Still, it is difficult to draw a clear-cut conclusion about how satisfied students are with education on distance, as Turner’s experts emphasize: “That’s because of the wide variation in the responses. There are groups of students who are very satisfied with online education, while there are also groups who are, in fact, very dissatisfied with distance education. And differences exist within institutions, across grade levels, and across educational levels.”
Teachers
Instructors say they have grown more proficient in delivering online instruction recently and, moreover, view certain digital teaching methods as adding value to traditional education. Examples include online explanations and instruction, which often better align with students’ learning styles and needs. In addition, teachers say that providing personalized instruction is easier through online channels.
“According to instructors, it’s easier to provide additional individual guidance to certain students online,” the researchers explain. “In addition, communication via a chat program is more accessible, which helps build a relationship of trust between students and instructors.”
On the other hand, teachers are currently dealing with a heavier workload. “Preparing and delivering distance education takes more time than in-person education. Eighty percent of teachers report spending more time now on lesson preparation, teaching, or organizing tests and exams.”
Furthermore, teachers find delivering distance education more challenging. For example, they are generally dissatisfied with conducting interactive lessons and hands-on training via online platforms. “This may be due to the more complex interactions that must take place in such work and teaching environments. How do you replace the workshop or the training kitchen? And how do student hairdressers find models? That’s not so easy.”
The researchers note that they encountered “extremely creative solutions,” in which teachers “certainly did not choose the easy way out.” “For example, teachers from hospitality programs filmed themselves in a liquor store to teach product knowledge about beverages. Students in culinary programs cooked meals at home, had their roommates evaluate them, and filmed the entire process. Instructors in a motor vehicle program used a webcam to observe their students’ cars and provided immediate guidance.”
Furthermore, about 75% of faculty members have had negative experiences with schedules while teaching remotely in recent months. These include, for example, schedules that changed without any prior consultation, or scheduled appointments that were not feasible. Several teachers also reported that it was not always clear to them which scheduled classes and meetings would take place and which would not.
The Future of Online Education
Would you like more information about the study? Please contact:
All insights into the lessons learned from the COVID-19 pandemic

What Educational Institutions Need to Do Now to Continue Innovating After the COVID-19 Crisis
It’s all hands on deck in education: all schools are closed, teachers are sick, and yet classes must go on. A lot is being asked of teachers, support staff, and
Colleges: Where Is the Real Innovation?
Education Colleges: Where Is the Real Innovation? Turner conducted a study on educational innovation among 25 deans and administrators at 14 colleges. Colleges: Where Is

The Future of Blended Education Has Begun
Turner conducted a survey of more than 1,500 students, faculty, and staff members at six higher education institutions. The study addressed the question on everyone’s mind in education: What can

Turner Publishes Study Titled “The Future of Blended Education Has Begun”
Turner conducted a survey of more than 1,500 students, faculty, and staff members at six higher education institutions. The study addressed the question on everyone’s mind in education: What can

What learning has the vocational education sector gained from the COVID-19 pandemic?
Turner, in collaboration with sixteen educational institutions, conducted a survey of more than 5,000 students, faculty, and staff to draw lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic. The goal was to answer

Turner publishes a research report titled “What Can Vocational Education Learn from the COVID-19 Pandemic?”
Fourteen vocational schools, together with HAS, Radboud University, and Turner, conducted a survey of more than 5,000 teachers, students, and staff members to draw lessons from this period. With a

De Telegraaf | Vocational Education in Trouble Due to Lack of Hands-On Classes
Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic De Telegraaf | Vocational Education in Trouble Due to Lack of Hands-On Classes De Telegraaf highlights the lack of hands-on

MBO Council | Study Shows Student and Faculty Well-Being Under Strain
Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic MBO Council | Study Shows Student and Faculty Well-Being Under Strain The MBO Council, the advocacy organization for vocational education

MBO Today | ‘Coronavirus Brings Lasting Change to Education’
Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic MBO Today | “COVID-19 Is Bringing About Lasting Changes in Education” MBO Today, the trade journal for professionals and administrators

“Monitoring the Impact of COVID-19 on Vocational Education and Higher Education”
In her letter to the House of Representatives, Minister van Engelshoven of the Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science takes stock of the situation in vocational education and higher education.

Consultancy.nl | Vocational students and teachers: “100% online education doesn’t work”
Consultancy.nl highlights a study conducted by Turner on the lessons learned during the COVID-19 pandemic, which surveyed 5,000 students, faculty, and staff members from sixteen educational institutions. Read the full

Consultancy.nl “How Students View 100% Online Education”
Consultancy.nl reports on our survey of more than 1,500 students, faculty, and staff members from six higher education institutions. The article focuses on the students’ perspective: How do they experience
Contact
We would like to get to know you.
Do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions!
Huize de Boom
Arnhemseweg 107
3832 GK Leusden
Phone: +31 (0)33 – 285 93 00
Email: info@turner.nl
Make an appointment
Would you like more information or a tailor-made quote? Fill in the form for a no-obligation appointment.
